If you are a runner with forefront pain/pain on the ball of your foot, this is for you. If you’re struggling with your diagnosis and want some non-doctor advice, you’re in luck. This is my journey on figuring out what the hell is wrong with my right foot. Injuries suck, but you got this! I wish you a speedy recovery.
I’m a runner, and was steadily increasing my mileage the last few weeks leading into mid December 2025. I was finishing up a 15 mile trail run when I felt a pain in my right forefront, as if I bruised it by jamming my foot into a protruding rock. Not fun, but not enough to end my run or even ruin my day. A little sore walking around barefoot later that day, but feeling 100% by the next morning.
I’d repeat this cycle, off and on, for a week. A little pain towards the end of my morning run, pain walking barefoot in the afternoon, but feeling better the next day. Maybe I’m just getting older (38 as I write this), maybe it was just a lingering bruise.
On one particular running workout, I did uphill treadmill for 30 minutes followed by 2 miles outdoors as a cooldown. The lingering 1-2 out of 10 pain was now a 5 out of 10. Yep. Something was wrong. And it was time to shut it down.
For my brain, the idea of not running is the equivalent of going to jail. But I forced myself to stop running for a week until it felt better and get back after it. 2 weeks later, I was still hobbling around. It hurt to walk, and it was time to fix this. The elliptical and indoor biking was getting old, fast.
I was a former all-in Google doctor, but now I’m a seasoned ChatGPT doctor w/ slight Google tendencies. I’ve also stayed at a few Holiday Inns in my day, so this evaluation would be easy. Early diagnosis was a stress fracture that I could verify with an x-ray.
Well, I ended up going to a real doctor and found out the x-ray was negative. The foot specialist said my high arches were “a tough foot shape that will give you difficulty your entire life. You’ll need to work on mobility. Good luck. You have Metatarsalgia.” Thanks doc.
Turns out Metatarsalgia means “pain in your foot”. No shit, doc. $250 to throw a overly complicated label on something I’ve known for 2 weeks.
This is the age of putting your health into your own hands, so back to Google and ChatGPT I went. The rabbit hole was deep: from a stress fracture too small for the x-ray to see, Morton’s neuroma, plantar fasciitis, plantar plate strain, etc. The options were endless, but it was time to get back to the basics and try to understand the pain a bit better.
After trying a variety of different diagnostic tests, I concluded I likely had a plantar plate strain (not to be confused with a full tear). The single toe dorsiflexion test was positive on the 2nd/3rd toe and pushing off with my right foot produced the most amount of pain. I don’t have any toe drifting/elevation, so this could be a false positive, but as of week 3, I’m fairly confident in my ChatGPT diagnosis.
Below is a list of tools and exercises I’ve tried to expedite my recovery and ease my pain. I’ve rated these 1-10, 10 being the best on a overly subjective, non-scientific scale. No affiliate links here. I’m no guru, but also not a grifter. Just my honest, uneducated opinion. If the links are broken, just Google around.
Recovery Tools
- Recovery sandals. 10/10. I bought the Kuailu recovery sandals off Amazon. I no longer walk around barefoot. These have drastically reduced my pain.
- New shoes. 10/10. I ordered a pair of Brooks Glycerin Max, which made a night and day difference with walking pain. I used Run Repeat to isolate a pair of shoes with 1) high shock absorption in the forefoot 2) lower heel drop versus my Nike Pegasus to take weight distribution off the forefront and 3) high sole stiffness to reduce the bending/dorsiflexion of my toes. I also ordered a pair of Hoka Skyward X’s, which are even stiffer with carbon plate, but not as strong in the two other categories. TBD on the success of the Hoka’s.
- Ribbon/figure eight taping for plantar plate injuries. 8/10. Here is a video of the plantar plate taping. This, along with the shoe stiffness, reduce the plantar flexion of the toes. Less plantar flexion = less stress and faster recovery.
- Massaging and stretching my calf. 8/10. I’ve struggled with Achilles issues, and usually plantar plate sprains are caused by issues further up the chain.
- Lacrosse ball to roll under foot. 8/10. This feels great. Everything is tight and I have high arches.
- Towel toe scrunches. 7/10. These don’t provide instant relief, but I can feel my foot getting stronger day to day from these.
- Foot Doming. 6/10. These are difficult to do. Mind muscle connection!
- Walking boot. 5/10. These were wildly uncomfortable for me. Probably a better option, but I’m going with the recovery sandals instead.
- Toe spacers. 3/10. I don’t think these do much.
- Insole inserts/orthotics. TBD. I ordered from Sole. Specifically the Active Medium with Met Pad. The met pad is interesting – it takes pressure off your metatarsals by placing a pad near your arch to distribute the weight. You can even make your own by cutting out some cardboard and taping it under your insole.
What’s next?
I’m midway through week 3 right now. My goal is to rehab and de-load my foot for the next few weeks. If I’m not progressing, I’ll go in for an MRI.

Leave a Reply